Jayadeep Hari & JamilJayadeep Hari & JamilJayadeep Hari & JamilJayadeep Hari & Jamil
  • About
  • Our People
    • Partners
    • Consultant
    • Associates
  • Practice Areas
  • Publications
    • Legal Updates
    • Legal Cauldron (Temporary suspended)
    • Articles
    • News & Bulletin
  • We Care
  • Careers
  • Contact Us

Legal Update 11 of 2022

    Home Legal Updates Legal Update 11 of 2022
    NextPrevious

    Legal Update 11 of 2022

    By jhj admin | Legal Updates | 0 comment | 14 June, 2022 | 0

    Does an employee demotion or re-grading amount to constructive dismissal?

    Case:

    Ng Teck Fay v. Mahkamah Perusahaan Malaysia & Anor. [2021] 10 CLJ 73, Court of Appeal

    Brief Facts:

    • The appellant (“Employee”) started working for the Company in 2008 as an Assistant General Manager. In 2014, the Employee accidentally shared an internal email with an outside party.

     

    • The Company issued the Employee a show cause letter. The employee apologized and was issued a warning letter.

     

    • After that, the Company also issued the Employee with two further letters — the first one entitled “change of job scope”. This meant that the employee’s scope of duties was reduced, and the second one entitled “job re-grading to senior manager” whereby the Employee was downgraded and demoted from Assistant General Manager to Senior manager.

     

    • When these letters were issued, the Employee was also told that he could resign if he disagreed with the contents of the letters. Four days after the demotion, the Employee opted to leave the Company, and claimed that he was constructively dismissed.

     

    • The Industrial Court dismissed the employee’s claims on the grounds:

             i. The re-grading/change of position did not involve any change to his salary and seniority, only changed his     

                benefits arising from the position of alignment of the new job grade and scope.

            ii. The employee failed to prove that the Company breached the relevant terms and conditions of his Employment

               contract which would entitle him to consider himself constructively dismissed.

    • The employee then challenged the Industrial Court’s decision at the High Court. The High Court dismissed the challenge. The Employee then filed an appeal to the Court of Appeal.

    COURT OF APPEAL DECISION - APPEAL ALLOWED!

    • Court of Appeal outlined 4 conditions that the employee must satisfy to claim he was constructively dismissed:

             i. There must be a breach of contract by the employer.
            ii. The breach must be sufficiently important to justify the employee leaving.
           iii. The employee must leave in response to the breach and not for some other unconnected reasons.
           iv. The employee must not unduly delay in terminating the contract or he would be deemed to have waived the      breach and agreed to vary contract

    • The Court of Appeal decided that the employee had satisfied these conditions and the employee was deemed to be constructively dismissed.

     

    • The re-grading resulted in the Employee having reduced responsibilities, and the demotion also involved the removal of two other employees who used to report to the Employee, as well as reduced benefits.

     

    • The CoA found that both the Industrial Court and High Court failed to consider that an employee could not be demoted or re-graded to a post which he never held before (the Employee was hired as an Assistant General Manager and was now asked to assume the post of Senior Manager), and that there was insufficient judicial appreciation of the totality of the evidence.

    No tags.

    jhj admin

    More posts by jhj admin

    Related Post

    • Legal Update 9 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Can a civil servant be dismissed from employment by a local authority without affording him the right to be heard? Case: PIHAK BERKUASA TATATERTIB MAJLIS PERBANDARAN SEBERANG PERAI & ANOR v. MUZIADI MUKHTAR [2020] 1Read more

    • Legal Update 10 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Can the payment of quit rent, assessment rates, electricity and water bills be used to prove ownership of property? Case: HS REALTY SDN BHD v. YOW HONG SOON [2020] 1 LNS 230 Brief Facts: HSRead more

    • Legal Update 11 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Can accused persons who are convicted of disobeying the Movement Control Order appeal for alternative punishment instead of imprisonment in the interest of justice? Case: CHIN CHEE WEI & ANOR V PP [2020] 1 LNSRead more

    • Legal Update 12 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Can a foreign national have a permanent contract of employment? Case: AHMAD ZAHRI MIRZA ABDUL HAMID v. AIMS CYBERJAYA SDN BHD [2020] 1 LNS 494 Brief Facts: Ahmad, an expatriate, received a letter of appointmentRead more

    • Legal Update 13 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Can the giving of legal advice by an adjudged bankrupt, whose practising certificate has been suspended, amount to practising law in contravention of the Legal Profession Act 1976? Case: DARSHAN SINGH KHAIRA v. ZULKEFLI HASHIMRead more

    • Legal Update 14 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Can individual parcel owners enforce rights relating to common property on their own behalf? Case: SYARIKAT EAST COAST & ORS v. MAKNA MUJUR SDN BHD & ORS [2020] 2 MLRA 440 Brief Facts: Syarikat EastRead more

    • Legal Update 15 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      When is the point of time when a debtor is considered to be unable to pay his debts? Case: AFFIN BANK BERHAD V. ABU BAKAR ISMAIL [2020] 2 MLRA 99 Brief Facts: Affin Bank BerhadRead more

    • Legal Update 16 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Whether an article containing allegations of corrupt practices and giving of bribes was defamatory to the owner of an education institution? Case: EAGLE ONE INVESTMENT LTD & ORS V. ASIA PACIFIC HIGHER LEARNING SDN BHDRead more

    Leave a Comment

    Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    NextPrevious

    JHJ Bulletin

    • S.Jeyaraman: The Magic of Memory
    • Andreas Dorn: Your Unconscious Mind on Change and Money

    Legal Updates

    • Legal Update 22 of 2022
    • Legal Update 21 of 2022
    • Legal Update 20 of 2022
    • Legal Update 19 of 2022
    • Legal Update 18 of 2022
    • Legal Update 17 of 2022
    • Legal Update 16 of 2022

    Legal Cauldron

    • 2
      0

      Legal Cauldron 1 of 2016

      Click here to view & download
    • 2
      0

      Legal Cauldron 2 of 2015

      Click here to view & download
    Copyright 2017 All Rights Reserved Contact Us         Like & Follow Us On:Facebook | Instagram | LinkedIn Disclaimer | Privacy Policy
    • About
    • Our People
      • Partners
      • Consultant
      • Associates
    • Practice Areas
    • Publications
      • Legal Updates
      • Legal Cauldron (Temporary suspended)
      • Articles
      • News & Bulletin
    • We Care
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
    Jayadeep Hari & Jamil