Jayadeep Hari & JamilJayadeep Hari & JamilJayadeep Hari & JamilJayadeep Hari & Jamil
  • About
  • Our People
    • Partners
    • Consultant
    • Associates
  • Practice Areas
  • Publications
    • Legal Updates
    • Legal Cauldron (Temporary suspended)
    • Articles
    • News & Bulletin
  • We Care
  • Careers
  • Contact Us

Legal Update 16 of 2021

    Home Legal Updates Legal Update 16 of 2021
    NextPrevious

    Legal Update 16 of 2021

    By jhj admin | Legal Updates | 0 comment | 6 December, 2021 | 0

    Can an Embassy rely on Sovereign Immunity in dismissing an employee unlawfully?

    Case:

    SUBRAMANIAM A/L LETCHIMINAN v THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA AND ANOTHER APPEAL [2021] MLJU 805

    Brief Facts:

    • Letchimanan (“the Workman”) had been working as a security guard for the USA Embassy (“the Embassy”) since 1998.

     

    • On 4.4.2008, the Workman received a phone call from an official of the Embassy that his employment had been terminated. No reasons were given.

     

    • The workman thought that he should at least be informed of the reasons for being sacked and so he wrote to the Embassy but was disappointed to receive no reply.

     

    • The Workman felt aggrieved that after serving for more than 10 years he was terminated without notice and with no reasons given.

     

    • The Workman thought he should lodge a police report to show his seriousness in pursuing justice and to accurately put on record what had happened to him.

     

    • He also filed a representation under section 20(1) of the Industrial Relations Act (“IRA”) with the Director General of Industrial Relations (“DGIR”) at the Kuala Lumpur Industrial Relations Department.

     

    • There was no progress on this issue until 10 years later, a letter from the DGIR office calling for a conciliation meeting on 28.9.2018.

     

    • The Embassy was present through its representative and the Workman was also present at the Kuala Lumpur Industrial Relations Department. However, no settlement was reached.

     

    • The Embassy sent a representation to the DGIR stating that sovereign immunity applied and that the matter should not be referred at all to the Industrial Court.

     

    • The Minister of Human Resources (“the Minister”) was subsequently informed by the DGIR that there was no resolution of the dispute between the workman and the Embassy.

     

    • After considering the representation of the parties, the Minister decided to refer the matter to the Industrial Court (“the Reference”). The Reference was made on 22.4.2019.

     

    • This prompted the Embassy to challenge by way of a Judicial Review application to the High Court arguing that state immunity applied and that the Minister was wrong in law to have referred the dispute to the Industrial Court.

     

    • The High Court agreed with the Embassy and quashed the reference by the Minister and a prohibition against the Industrial Court from adjudicating the Minister’s reference.

     

    • Both the Workman and the Minister had appealed to the Court of Appeal.

    COURT OF APPEAL DECISION – APPEAL ALLOWED!

    • The Court of Appeal stated that the High Court Judge had erred in his decision to allow the Judicial Review application and to quash the Minister’s decision to refer the dispute to the Industrial Court.

     

    • The issue of whether the dismissal of the workman as a security guard involved the question of the exercise of a sovereign act that attracts restrictive immunity or otherwise would depend on findings of fact with respect to the nature of his job. That exercise is best undertaken by the Industrial Court.

     

    • The Industrial Court could now proceed to hear the dispute.
    No tags.

    jhj admin

    More posts by jhj admin

    Related Post

    • Legal Update 9 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Can a civil servant be dismissed from employment by a local authority without affording him the right to be heard? Case: PIHAK BERKUASA TATATERTIB MAJLIS PERBANDARAN SEBERANG PERAI & ANOR v. MUZIADI MUKHTAR [2020] 1Read more

    • Legal Update 10 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Can the payment of quit rent, assessment rates, electricity and water bills be used to prove ownership of property? Case: HS REALTY SDN BHD v. YOW HONG SOON [2020] 1 LNS 230 Brief Facts: HSRead more

    • Legal Update 11 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Can accused persons who are convicted of disobeying the Movement Control Order appeal for alternative punishment instead of imprisonment in the interest of justice? Case: CHIN CHEE WEI & ANOR V PP [2020] 1 LNSRead more

    • Legal Update 12 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Can a foreign national have a permanent contract of employment? Case: AHMAD ZAHRI MIRZA ABDUL HAMID v. AIMS CYBERJAYA SDN BHD [2020] 1 LNS 494 Brief Facts: Ahmad, an expatriate, received a letter of appointmentRead more

    • Legal Update 13 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Can the giving of legal advice by an adjudged bankrupt, whose practising certificate has been suspended, amount to practising law in contravention of the Legal Profession Act 1976? Case: DARSHAN SINGH KHAIRA v. ZULKEFLI HASHIMRead more

    • Legal Update 14 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Can individual parcel owners enforce rights relating to common property on their own behalf? Case: SYARIKAT EAST COAST & ORS v. MAKNA MUJUR SDN BHD & ORS [2020] 2 MLRA 440 Brief Facts: Syarikat EastRead more

    • Legal Update 15 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      When is the point of time when a debtor is considered to be unable to pay his debts? Case: AFFIN BANK BERHAD V. ABU BAKAR ISMAIL [2020] 2 MLRA 99 Brief Facts: Affin Bank BerhadRead more

    • Legal Update 16 of 2020

      By jhj admin | 0 comment

      Whether an article containing allegations of corrupt practices and giving of bribes was defamatory to the owner of an education institution? Case: EAGLE ONE INVESTMENT LTD & ORS V. ASIA PACIFIC HIGHER LEARNING SDN BHDRead more

    Leave a Comment

    Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    NextPrevious

    JHJ Bulletin

    • S.Jeyaraman: The Magic of Memory
    • Andreas Dorn: Your Unconscious Mind on Change and Money

    Legal Updates

    • Legal Update 22 of 2022
    • Legal Update 21 of 2022
    • Legal Update 20 of 2022
    • Legal Update 19 of 2022
    • Legal Update 18 of 2022
    • Legal Update 17 of 2022
    • Legal Update 16 of 2022

    Legal Cauldron

    • 2
      0

      Legal Cauldron 1 of 2016

      Click here to view & download
    • 2
      0

      Legal Cauldron 2 of 2015

      Click here to view & download
    Copyright 2017 All Rights Reserved Contact Us         Like & Follow Us On:Facebook | Instagram | LinkedIn Disclaimer | Privacy Policy
    • About
    • Our People
      • Partners
      • Consultant
      • Associates
    • Practice Areas
    • Publications
      • Legal Updates
      • Legal Cauldron (Temporary suspended)
      • Articles
      • News & Bulletin
    • We Care
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
    Jayadeep Hari & Jamil